Photo by www.phototravelpages.com

Can your body make you sin? If so, are you still responsible?

Yes, and yes. However, in answering these questions, we might be missing a better question than that of responsibility, but I’ll get to that later…

I suppose you might like some defense of my position. I will do so both in this post and in the one to follow. Obviously, I’m going to tackle this from a Christian perspective that cares about sin and wants to think carefully about ontology (what it means to be human).

Some background beliefs

1. In the Christian life sin matters. Sin is whatever we do or are that violates God’s definition of holiness. In this life, sin is inescapable. Sin is that which fallen creatures do all the time. Thankfully, God provides a way of escape from the logical consequences of sin via the cross. Despite (no, because of the power of) this gift from God, Christians still care about eradicating sin even though it is not possible. It stands to reason, then, that we should observe the sources of sin in our life in order to stop them.

2. The classic Christian view of human nature is that we are made of two substances: body and soul. We are not just our physical bodies but something intangible was imputed to us when God breathed life into Adam. Our soul allows us to worship God. The bible refers to our soul in various ways: will, heart, desires, etc. The soul is the driver of the will and therefore responsible for the moral direction of our actions. Early theologically oriented scientists (think Descartes) assumed the existence of the soul but looked to explain how the intangible soul connected to the tangible body. Now with the advances in neuroscience we have better explanatory power in describing the action of thoughts, feelings, and knowing. However, the will remains a mystery. While we can explain neural networks and what the brain does when desiring something, we cannot yet explain WHY we want or desire certain things.

Some philosophers and theologians have attempted to deal with classic dualism by suggesting that we are only one substance. I am not capable of succinctly defending this position so I point you to Nancey Murphy and a review of her book here. She does a masterful job defending non-reducible physicalism.

Key questions and a partial answer

Whether two substances or one, the question we raise in this post is whether our bodies, against our will, can cause us to sin. And maybe more importantly, is there anything gained or lost if it is true that our bodies (apart from will) can cause us to sin? Are we culpable for such sins? 

Let me take these two questions in succession:

Question One:

Is it possible that my body (against or apart from my will) might cause me to sin?

Partial Answer:

1. We do nothing apart from our cells. We mediate all worship, desire, etc. through our cells. When we do good or evil, body and will are always involved.

2. Sin is not merely an act, but a disposition. All of me is tainted and not functioning as it was originally intended, including my physical body (and don’t I feel the effects of being over 45!). The dualist position is more in danger of treating sin as only what we consciously choose.

3. I don’t have to know that I broke the law (biblical or federal) to be guilty of violating the law. I didn’t know I was speeding but I still got a ticket. In the OT, lack of intention or knowledge violating the law did not protect against impurity or guilt (e.g., Lev. 4:22; 5:3).

4. If the body is broken and under sin’s curse it stands to reason that our bodies function in ways that are out of accord with our will. If they can move without our control (e.g., Parkinsonian tremors, Tourette-based tics) can they not also move in such a way that violates God’s design for us. We have some scientific evidence of this. Stimulate a certain part of the brain, and you will experience rageful feelings. Stimulate another part and you may have sexual thoughts. Consider a person with Tourettes Syndrome. There is some evidence of temporary volitional control (a surgeon is able to stop a tic during an operation) but other evidence suggests that these same tics (including cursing) burst out of the person despite conscious effort to eliminate.

Saying yes to this question violates our Western sensibilities.

Question Two:

 If we accept that our bodies can act against or without the will, what do we gain or lose? I think the primary concern by many would be that somehow we will either be held culpable for sins we didn’t want to commit or claim innocence for sins we willfully committed. And this gets under our skin here in the West.

We want only to be held accountable for things we did do and not held accountable for things we either didn’t do or didn’t have any control over.

Partial Answer:

It strikes us as evil to be held accountable for that which we didn’t know was wrong. I once got a ticket for making a u-turn on a Chicago city street at 11 pm when no one (but the cop!) was around. There were no signs. I wasn’t familiar with Chicago rules, was lost in an unsavory neighborhood. And yet I still got the ticket. It didn’t seem right. But I did violate the law.

Our American judicial system isn’t the only system that holds us accountable for involuntary acts. Romans teaches us that because of Adam’s sin, all are sinners. I bear the culpability for his sin (and I make plenty of my own as well). I bear the impact of his choices in my entire being. Not only am I culpable, but I may need to confess my forefather’s sins. We see several OT prophets confessing the sins of the community—as if they were their own.

So, in short, I think we can answer yes to the question about whether our bodies can make us sin. They can because we (body and soul) are tainted by the Fall. It doesn’t make us more or less out of sorts with God whether our sin is chosen or involuntary. Happily, God doesn’t forgive only willful sin, he forgives sin period. And he makes it possible to not sin by imputing his righteousness to us.

Is there a better question?

Still thinking about culpability? If so, check back tomorrow for a little vignette to chew on along with a better question than just responsibility for behaviors.


Phil Monroe is Professor of Counseling & Psychology and Director of the MA in Counseling program at Biblical Seminary. He maintains a private practice with Diane Langberg & Associates. You can follow his personal and professional musings at www.wisecounsel.wordpress.comor read more about it at http://www.biblical.edu/index.php/phillip-monroe.

 

Comments 

 
0 #7 Kimberly Winters 2012-10-25 22:58
First of all: I can't believe they gave you a ticket!

Second: Thanks for this post - very helpful and exactly describes what I believe.
Quote
 
 
0 #6 Philip Monroe 2012-10-23 20:51
By the way, this view doesn't discount Rom 1. We each have, left to our own accord, dispositionally moved away from God. That doesn't mean each and every sin is a volitional choice.

Your thots and response?
Quote
 
 
+1 #5 Philip Monroe 2012-10-23 20:51
Whit, great questions/comments. First, I would argue that you are your body. Your body is not some appendage to you. All parts of your body are prone to sin and unable not to sin in this life. Does this mean that we are bound always to sin? No. But, despite 1 Cor 10:13, you and I still sin and can't stop it. Thus, I would argue that in principle, your heart/mind/body works in ways you do not want it to and yet it still sins (a la Rom 7). Because of the fall and because of our proclivities to be God, we (body, soul, mind, etc.) all moves in directions. So, the fact that my body continues on that path without my full consent does not let me off the hook. Further, I don't think anything in Scripture promises perfection even while we are promised the power to say no to sin. Thus, my entire fallen body moves in a direction toward sin.
Quote
 
 
0 #4 Whit Wilson 2012-10-23 16:28
All that being said, without a doubt, I have much to learn here and am eager to hear your thoughts and reflections.
Quote
 
 
0 #3 Whit Wilson 2012-10-23 16:28
In other contexts, particularly Romans 1, sin is described as being first a volitional choice to worship the creature rather than the creator, which then results in God giving us over to the sin (which I think could explain why people get to a point of no longer being aware of their sin).

I would humbly argue in light of these texts that the idea of our bodies not being able to force us to sin is not merely a Western notion, but a Biblical one.

I'm quite comfortable saying that our bodies make us significantly more pre-disposed and inclined to sin. Without a doubt, the grace of God in my own physiology makes it such that I struggle less with certain sins than others. So we are correct in saying that just because one person struggles with a certain addiction and another doesn't is not necessarily because of any kind of spiritual superiority. But to go the next step and say that our bodies "make" us sin is one step too far I think.
Quote
 
 
0 #2 Whit Wilson 2012-10-23 16:27
Dr. Monroe,

Thanks for referring to your posts here. I enjoyed reading them (actually I'm just about to read the second one now).

If you don't mind, I'd like to push back a bit here.

I guess I'm somewhat uncomfortable with the idea that our body can "make" us sin (i.e. force, uncontrollably cause, etc.). You mention the passages in Leviticus (which I think one could argue for a different interpretation based on the context). But if we are to account for the full testimony of Scripture here (which of course we both desire to do), how then do we understand I Corinthians 10:13? ("...but with temptation, He (God) will provide a way of escape, that you may be able to endure it.")
Quote
 
 
+1 #1 Cynthia Pollet 2012-06-29 11:14
Such an applicable question for current issues in mental health--and in the church as well. Jesus said that if your right eye or right hand cause you to stumble, get rid of them, because it is better to be handicapped than go to hell (my paraphrase of Matt. 5:28-30). I have often interpreted this verse by focusing on the word "if." Earlier in this passage, Jesus equates looking lustfully at a woman with committing adultery. It would seem that the self-mutilation verses really indicate that the sin truly stems from our hearts--where our desires lie.
I still have many questions about what God requires of us in regards to our sin. Overall, scripture indicates that God looks at the heart. If we seek after God and trust in the redemptive work of Christ allowing the Holy Spirit to convict us of personal sin, I think we're on the right track. For those who have conditions that are beyond their control, that is for God to judge.
Quote
 

Add comment


Security code
Refresh

Blog Mission

The purpose of this blog will be to expand the influence of our faculty, maintain contact with our graduates, and invite other friends to think with us about important biblical and theological ideas.

Biblical's Faculty

Biblical’s Faculty:

We are committed to ongoing engagement with culture and the world for the sake of our witness to the Gospel, and to continual learning from Christians in other cultural settings.

Latest Blog Entries

Written on 16 April 2014 - by Philip Monroe
Written on 14 April 2014 - by Drew Hart
Written on 10 April 2014 - by R. Todd Mangum
Written on 09 April 2014 - by R. Todd Mangum
Written on 08 April 2014 - by R. Todd Mangum
Written on 07 April 2014 - by R. Todd Mangum
Written on 04 April 2014 - by Charles Zimmerman
Written on 02 April 2014 - by Stephanie Lowery
Written on 28 March 2014 - by Dave Dunbar
Written on 21 March 2014 - by Stephanie Lowery

Previous Blog Entries

Follow Biblical

Follow us on the following sites and receive notifications on upcoming events and blog entries:

Follow Biblical on facebookFollow Biblical on Twitterg+_64_black

Contact Admissions

800.235.4021 x146

215.368.5000 x146

215.368.4913 (fax)

 

admissions@biblical.edu

Stay Connected with Biblical

Follow us on the following sites:

Follow Biblical on facebookFollow Biblical on TwitterFollow Biblical on YouTubeg+_64_black
Or simply call us at...
800.235.4021 x146 or 215.368.5000 x146

Support Biblical by Giving

800.235.4021 x162

215.368.5000 x162

215.368.7002 (fax)

 

development@biblical.edu

Home

Site Login