Michael Dunn Murder Trial

Jordan Davis and Shadows of Trayvon Martin: Some Comments from a Theological Perspective

This past week, a jury convicted Michael Dunn of three counts of second degree murder, but deadlocked on the count of first degree murder. Michael Dunn is the Florida man who fired ten shots into an SVU full of teenage boys, killing one of them. Apparently, the shooting followed an argument that started over Dunn’s objecting to the loud music coming from the van in a gas station parking lot. Oh, and did I mention? Dunn is white; the teenage boys, black.

This has become another case, like the Trayvon Martin/George Zimmerman case less than a year ago (also in Florida), in which different reactions to the case have fallen along racial lines — African Americans voicing alignment with the victims of the shooting, whites urging “caution” or even sympathy for the perception of threat to the one doing the shooting.

African American leaders — including the president of the U.S., and including leaders among Biblical Seminary’s graduates and constituents — have called upon their brothers and sisters in the empowered, majority culture to speak out against this situation as an injustice: African-American youths, especially young men, being killed, and the killing being exonerated officially by the courts.

In response to this call, I posted some comments, originally, on a Facebook page. These thoughts are admittedly only starter thoughts, and far from adequate to address either the seriousness or the complexity of the issues involved. But I post them here in the effort to: 1) further the conversation; and 2) address some of the elements of injustice involved in the hope of beginning to redress some of them — even if too little, too late, better than no start at all.

First of all, I cannot weigh in as a lawyer; and I can't say I've followed the Michael Dunn/Jordan Davis case at all closely. I will make an observation or two as a theologian -- observations that would apply to this case as well as the Trayvon Martin/George Zimmerman case, I think:

  1. Americans, generally, are thankful for the "presumption of innocence" that underpins the American justice system. Fine -- but we Christians should realize this is different from the biblical system of justice that God set up. When someone was killed in the Old Testament, it was a race to the city of refuge. If the "avenger of blood" caught the killer before he (or she) made it to the city of refuge, the presumption was the killer must be GUILTY (not innocent.). I'm reluctant to say we should "go back" to that system -- but I will say that the "cheat" that the Martin family felt at their son's murder and the killer "presumed innocent" -- like Jordan Davis's parents now (mitigated some, I guess, by this killer's at least being convicted of some manslaughter charges) -- are instincts that, biblically speaking, are affirmed, not rebuked or condemned. When someone is killed -- when a teenage boy is killed, perhaps particularly -- the "presumption of innocence" may be too great a presumption. "Injustice" may lie in just such presumption. (How to fix it is a complex question, but nonetheless . . . ).
  2. American manslaughter and self-defense laws are riddled (in combination with “presumption of innocence” of a killer) with notions of “did the killer defending himself genuinely believe his life was in danger?” . . . But what about when those “genuine beliefs” of one's life being in danger are themselves rooted in (“genuinely”) racist presuppositions? The racism is then potentially REWARDED with "right to self defense." This, too, seems an injustice.
  3. In this case, there was definitely a “clash of cultures” going on, too. The “loud music” was considered by the mainstream culture occupant as a nuisance, a “disturbance of the peace” that should be corrected. On the other hand, the attempt to squelch or silence the music by the minority culture was taken as an affront to the culture’s very identity, and as yet another act of unprovoked disrespect, at least — and maybe even an attempt to smother and oppress legitimate cultural expression. With a hermeneutic of suspicion and distrust being the baseline frame of reference for both sides, there was no way that divide was going to be bridged at all civilly at that moment. But then (and this goes for the Zimmerman/Martin case, too) . . .
  4. Who brings a gun into it? . . . The expression is an old one, “There's no pulling the bullet back in the gun (once it's fired),” but, sheez, people -- that's not just a cliché; it's TRUE. Pulling a gun is a power-play to begin with; and then -- taking a young life with it? . . .

Who can fail to recognize the injustice of that? . . .

About the Author

Todd Mangum

Dr. R. Todd Mangum

Todd Mangum is the Academic Dean and Professor of Theology at Biblical. He is ordained by the Southern Baptist Convention. Todd is the author of The Dispensational-Covenantal Rift, and co-author (with Dr. Paul Pettit of the Howard Hendricks Leadership Center in Dallas, TX) of the just-released book, Blessed are the Balanced: Following Jesus into the Academy (Kregel), and of several articles seeking to bridge divides among Bible-believing Christians. He is married to Linda and they have three sons.

Add comment

Security code

Sign-up Today

Join thousands of students, faculty, and staff who are following Jesus into the world. You will receive notification when a new blog is posted, and be receive help in your place in life.

Follow Biblical

Follow us on the following sites and receive notifications on upcoming events and blog entries:

Follow Biblical on facebookFollow Biblical on Twitterg+_64_black

Latest Blog Entries

Written on 17 June 2016 - by R. Todd Mangum
Written on 02 February 2016 - by Kyuboem Lee
Written on 24 December 2015 - by Philip Monroe
Written on 17 December 2015 - by Philip Monroe
Written on 15 December 2015 - by Derek Cooper
Written on 03 December 2015 - by Derek Cooper
Written on 01 December 2015 - by Philip Monroe
Written on 24 November 2015 - by Kyuboem Lee
Written on 19 November 2015 - by Chang Hoon Oh
Written on 12 November 2015 - by David Lamb

Previous Blog Entries

Contact Admissions

800.235.4021 x146

215.368.5000 x146

215.368.4913 (fax)



Stay Connected with Biblical

Follow us on the following sites:

Follow Biblical on facebookFollow Biblical on TwitterFollow Biblical on YouTubeg+_64_black
Or simply call us at...
800.235.4021 x146 or 215.368.5000 x146

Support Biblical by Giving

800.235.4021 x130

215.368.5000 x130

215.368.2301 (fax)